The root of LocalVox's success was an unwavering commitment to the new opportunity. Perhaps the biggest challenge was in rallying employees around the new mission. "The inertia people have is tremendous," says Sumner. "You have to be really, really diligent to look for the before-pivot behaviors and snuff them out with real fervor."
The effort was ultimately worth it. LocalVox grew into a leading marketing services business and was acquired by a subsidiary of the Blackstone Group just three years later.
Think Broadly About the Value Already Built
A pivot doesn't necessarily require a completely new start. Often, legacy products or features prove highly useful—just not the way imagined. Slack's original gaming product never gained traction, but the internal messaging tool the founders created became the foundation for the office communications behemoth that Slack is today.
As a founder, be open to the possibility that new ideas and opportunities may present themselves as byproducts of previous efforts. When they do, think through smart applications and business models. Josh Anton, the founder of Drunk Mode, an app preventing users from making embarrassing late-night calls, did just that after his original plan hit turbulence. Drunk Mode gained traction—mostly with college students—after MTV heralded it as "your new best friend." The third-party location-tracking software built into the app, however, was draining users' phone batteries. "I knew, there was no way the economic model for location would work if it was draining batteries," says Anton.
The team set to work on developing its own, more efficient location-tracking software. Soon, they realized that for all its success, the market for Drunk Mode was limited. "We had validated our product-market fit, but we may have overestimated the [size of the] market," Anton says.
As the new location software topped expectations, Anton began thinking about what he could do with it. He quickly identified dozens of location-based marketing companies as potential competitors and mapped out their areas of focus. In doing so, he uncovered an open opportunity to capture location data from a network of publishers. The company changed its name to X-Mode and now reaches 30 million people a day from the apps, websites and out-of-home media that leverage its location data.
Getting Everyone on Board
Of course, in any major business overhaul, buy-in from key stakeholders is imperative, starting with the investors and board. Javice's board happily supported her decision to pivot Tap'd and came back with a term sheet once the new business model had been proven. For Nearsay, a healthy new revenue stream easily convinced the board to get behind the new direction. X-Mode's Anton waited to tell the board until the company had spent nine months developing the new product. "They thought it was amazing," he says.
Other stakeholders can be equally important. Javice, for instance, alienated her initial team by continually peppering them with good news, only to suddenly lay off most employees. She partly blames herself, acknowledging she handled the communication poorly, sparking surprise and hard feelings.
Sometimes, the founder is the last stakeholder to come around. "The trickiest part for founders is walking away from your baby and starting fresh," says Ivan Gaviria, a partner at Gunderson Dettmer, a Silicon Valley law firm that has advised startups for decades. "Being able to say, 'Hey, what we're doing is not going to be big enough or fast enough.'"
That was the case for Anton: "For me, the hard part was shutting down Drunk Mode, hard for my ego and my soul, but I had a fiduciary responsibility to our investors. So I made the hard call."