Standing out in a competitive market
There were companies trying to do aggregation before Plaid. Were you at all nervous about the fact that the market opportunity had been tried and didn't seem to lead anywhere big?
Yes and no. The biggest issue raising money was exactly that point. There were two companies in the space, Yodlee and CashEdge, and none had achieved breakout growth. That in one sense made the market look small. However, in another sense, it gave us this fantastic opportunity because we had a belief that the previous attempts were not focused on the right style of digitization.
We had a deep belief in "personal financial management plus" tools that could also do things. Robo-investing is a really great example of a category that is PFM plus. They analyze your spending and then figure out how to execute on it. The second belief was in embedded finance (where certain financial services become integral to the working of other apps) which is largely a trend that we're seeing play out.
Another advantage we had was a belief that developers themselves are a great distribution channel. Everyone in the market at the time was selling top down. We wanted to build a bottoms up sales process to the point that we didn't do enterprise sales until this year really at any sort of scale.
Finally, we had a team that was maniacally focused and worked ridiculously hard in order to go out and chase the challenge. Everyone had this very deep belief in the mission and the outcome we were trying to create. We had this mantra of "make money easier for everyone."
The rise of consumer fintech
Consumer-facing fintech has seen a pretty crazy explosion of popularity both in terms of usage, but also in terms of investment over the last five, six years. Why has this industry grown so fast? Why now?
If you talk to the early fintech companies, anyone that wanted to move money had to go out and figure out how to become their own money transmitter. Then, along comes a Stripe, for example, or a Plaid, or many of the new infrastructure companies that are out there, and even the digitization of the credit bureaus.
Basically all of the foundational elements of building a consumer fintech company went from being very hard in 2012 to being much easier certainly circa 2017, 2018. So, you start to see the maturation of companies that could take advantage of all that stuff. The complexity of issuing a card even five years ago was incredibly high. The amount of overhead, the size of your compliance team, the size of your risk and fraud team, all that stuff meant that only large companies could do it. Since then, the complexity has gone down, the simplicity has gone up.
We like to believe that Plaid had a little bit to do with it, but frankly it was just a timing thing where lots of companies built great infrastructure all at the same time. That enabled this consumer fintech wave to really expand.
Navigating corporate investments
Plaid took some investment along the way from corporate investors (including American Express, Citi, Visa, MasterCard, and Goldman Sachs). What are the tradeoffs or considerations for taking money from corporate investors and when to do so?
Financial institutions are an important part of the ecosystem that we serve. We really wanted to build brand recognition and trust within traditional financial services and taking money from these corporate investors was one way to do that. [We were] an infrastructure provider that had 25 to 30 people and were connecting millions of consumer accounts through our system. From the earliest days, we'd invested in fantastic privacy and security controls, and really made that a huge focus. However, we also needed that to be publicly recognized.
Bringing together this consortium of financial institutions to lend input and credence to the company was really crucial. We got a lot of advantages as well by having contacts on the bank side making sure that we were talking to the right people. Many of these financial institutions turned into long term Plaid customers, and I think that's really fantastic. But the initial impetus for us was about credibility .
Balancing investment and independence
Was it difficult to create the dynamic that brought in corporate investors with the right mindset, but not wanting to be beholden to any one strategic relationship?
It was a huge concern of ours. We wanted to be thoughtful about how to make sure that when we work together, everyone wins. This meant first making sure corporate partners were treated fairly and consistently and reducing controls on the business that could create conflicts of interest like funding control and blocking rights. We also focused on creating strong points of contact with our team to develop partnerships with these investors.
The future of fintech
What would you imagine is going to occur in the next three to five years in financial services or fintech?
This morning I tweeted that Square's market cap is approaching that of Goldman Sachs, which is a completely crazy thing to me. PayPal is approximately equal to Bank of America. It's been amazing to see tech-enabled digital finance now truly chasing and perhaps at some point surpassing a lot of the more traditional incumbents.
As we look ahead, the first trend that I expect to come out of this is increasing digitization of the incumbents. I think it's hard for the incumbents to do the level of technology investment that's required to fully compete with the more tech-forward or tech-centric firms.
The biggest banks can make this technological investment. The medium sized banks barely can get there. The smallest banks don't have any technologists on staff, so they're really relying on outsourcing there. I suspect that we'll see a rise of enablement tools particularly in the US for banks (ranked) 25 through 11,000. That'll be an interesting trend.
(On the consumer side) 80% are saying that they believe they can live their financial life fully digitally or they don't need to go back into a bank branch. That is a huge step forward. I suspect that we'll see a lot of the big banks chase that and play catch up.
Then, the last trend is embedded finance. We're seeing big technology companies, like Uber, for example, have so many different bits and pieces of financial services that are embedded — ways to pay their drivers, give loans or leases to their drivers, give consumers rewards, stored value, the card, so many of these different things. This concept of every company having embedded financial services in different digital experiences, I suspect that will continue in a big way. I think there are great businesses to be built to enable that.